The Influence Of Die/Mold Materials On Heat Treatment Distortion

Nov 02, 2026

Leave a message

              The Influence of Die/Mold Materials on Heat Treatment Distortion

 

The influence of material on heat treatment distortion encompasses both the chemical composition of the steel and its initial microstructure. In terms of the material itself, distortion is primarily affected by how its composition influences factors such as hardenability and the martensite-start (Ms) temperature.

 

When carbon tool steel undergoes water-oil dual-medium quenching from a standard quenching temperature, significant thermal stresses develop above the Ms temperature. As the material cools below the Ms point, the transformation of austenite into martensite generates transformation (microstructural) stresses; however, due to the low hardenability of carbon tool steel, these transformation stresses remain relatively small. Furthermore, since the Ms temperature is not particularly high, the steel's plasticity is already quite limited by the time the martensitic transformation occurs-making plastic deformation difficult. Consequently, the distortion characteristics dictated by thermal stresses prevail, typically resulting in the contraction of the die or mold cavity. Conversely, if the quenching temperature is raised (above 850°C), transformation stresses may become the dominant factor, potentially causing the cavity to expand.

                                                1

When dies or molds are fabricated from low-alloy tool steels-such as 9Mn2V, 9SiCr, CrWMn, or GCr15-the patterns of quenching-induced distortion are similar to those of carbon tool steels, though the magnitude of the distortion is generally smaller.

 

In the case of certain high-alloy steels, such as Cr12MoV, the higher content of carbon and alloying elements results in a lower Ms temperature. This leads to a greater amount of retained austenite following the quench, which offsets the volumetric expansion caused by the formation of martensite. As a result, the overall distortion after quenching is quite minimal. Typically, when such materials are quenched via air cooling, forced-air cooling, or a molten salt bath, the die or mold cavity tends to undergo slight expansion. However, if the quenching temperature is excessively high, the proportion of retained austenite increases, which may instead cause the cavity to contract. When molds are manufactured from carbon structural steels (such as 45 steel) or certain alloy structural steels (such as 40Cr), their relatively high $M_s$ (martensite-start) temperatures come into play. As the martensitic transformation begins at the surface, the core remains at a higher temperature, possessing lower yield strength and a degree of plasticity. Consequently, the transient tensile structural stress exerted by the surface on the core can easily exceed the core's yield strength, causing the mold cavity to expand.

                                             2

The initial microstructure of the steel also significantly influences quenching deformation. This "initial microstructure" encompasses factors such as the grade of inclusions, the degree of banding, the extent of compositional segregation, and the orientation of free carbide distribution, as well as the specific microstructures resulting from various preliminary heat treatments (e.g., pearlite, tempered sorbite, or tempered troostite). For mold steels, the primary concerns are carbide segregation and the morphology and distribution of the carbides.

 

In high-carbon, high-alloy steels (such as those of the Cr12 type), the impact of carbide segregation on quenching deformation is particularly pronounced. Carbide segregation leads to compositional non-uniformity once the steel is heated to an austenitic state, resulting in varying $M_s$ temperatures across different regions. Under identical cooling conditions, the transformation from austenite to martensite occurs at different times in different areas. Furthermore, the specific volume of the resulting martensite varies depending on its local carbon content; in some low-carbon or low-alloy regions, martensite may fail to form entirely-yielding bainite or troostite instead. Collectively, these factors result in non-uniform deformation of the component following the quenching process. The distribution morphology of carbides-whether granular or fibrous-affects the expansion and contraction of the matrix, which in turn influences the deformation that occurs during heat treatment. Typically, a fibrous carbide distribution leads to significant expansion of the mold cavity in the direction of the fibers, while contraction occurs in the direction perpendicular to the fibers (though this effect is less pronounced). To mitigate this, some manufacturers specify that the surface containing the mold cavity should be oriented perpendicular to the direction of the carbide fibers. Conversely, when carbides are distributed uniformly in a granular form, the mold cavity tends to undergo uniform expansion or contraction.

                                           3

Furthermore, the microstructural state prior to the final heat treatment also influences deformation. For instance, a microstructure consisting of globular pearlite exhibits a lower tendency for deformation after quenching compared to one consisting of lamellar pearlite. Consequently, for molds with strict deformation tolerances, it is common practice to perform a quench-and-temper treatment (refining) after rough machining, followed by finish machining and the final heat treatment.